Todays’ higher education is changing fast. It requires delivering top-notch academics and boosting student success. Also, creating a campus life that is exceptional. The trust in higher education has dropped from 57% to 36% in the last ten years1. Universities now must show their value clearly to students, employers, and the public.
This article will share unique views on what’s shaking the higher education sector. It will offer solutions for achieving top-quality education. For example, we’ll look at the leadership challenge for college presidents. Their average time in the role has dropped from 8.5 years to 5.9 years since 2006. Plus, 55% of them plan to retire within five years1. We’ll see what’s needed to make a strong and lasting leadership team.
Moreover, we will explore what makes students succeed. This includes their background, high school experiences, and choices they make before college. We will also look at what educational programs and activities work best. For instance, the University of North Carolina System shows big success: 94% of their undergrad programs and 91% of grad programs were a great investment for students1. This success can be a model for other universities to boost scholarly growth.
Key Takeaways
- The higher education landscape is facing a crisis of confidence, with the share of Americans expressing high trust in the value of higher education declining sharply.
- Institutions must articulate a compelling value proposition to attract and retain students, while addressing the leadership crisis facing college presidents.
- Student success is a multifaceted challenge, requiring a deep understanding of student backgrounds, precollege experiences, and engagement in effective educational practices.
- Leveraging data-driven insights from leading institutions like the University of North Carolina System can guide universities in delivering a transformative learning experience.
- Fostering a culture of innovation, global engagement, and a commitment to student outcomes is essential for higher education excellence.
The Outcomes Era: Articulating a Compelling Value Proposition
Many people in the U.S. don’t trust colleges like they used to. This is because they feel higher education doesn’t help everyone move up in society equally. To fix this, schools need to talk about education in a way that meets what students, families, and even employers want. They need to focus on how well students do after they graduate, how much debt they have, and how this all pays off2.
Institutions to Watch
The University of North Carolina System is leading the charge by showing clear info about how well students and schools do by program. This info is easy for anyone to find. On a larger scale, efforts are being made to better understand different aspects of higher education, including a focus on economic and social progress. Behind this push are groups that give schools the “okay” to operate, like the Higher Learning Commission. They too are putting a bigger emphasis on how students succeed after they earn their degree2.
In the years ahead, schools will be all about the results they achieve, the worth of their degree programs, and how these benefit society and the economy2. Those that can clearly show what they offer in these respects will really stand out2.
“The outcomes era is characterized by a shift in the perception of institutions as maintainers of inequality rather than facilitators of social mobility.”
To do well in this crucial time, colleges must be open about what they do and prove they make a positive difference economically and for society. They should also show they are into life-long learning and teaching the skills people need in the work world. By doing this, they will be in a great place in the outcomes era2.
Higher Education Excellence: Addressing the Leadership Crisis
Today’s college presidents are under a lot of stress. They deal with money problems, criticism of diversity efforts, and focus on student success. They also face demands from many different people3. This mix of troubles and differing views has led to a lack of experienced leaders. The time the average president spends in charge has dropped from 8.5 years to 5.9 years3.
The lack of leadership options hurts universities all around. Not preparing enough people to lead makes it worse3. Many top leaders at colleges come from education. But they may find it hard to manage today’s complex university world3. On the other hand, candidates from outside, like business or government, may not understand higher education’s special needs.
Fixing this crisis needs several steps. Universities should rethink their management, money ways, and how they react to change. They also should connect better with the public and be ready to take on new chances3. How universities make decisions needs to change so they can act faster and better meet their goals3.
Training new leaders is key to solving the problem. Some programs, such as those at Greenville Technical College, are already working well4. These show others how to help students succeed and bring in more people. Leaders like Kent Syverud of Syracuse have also made a big difference. They’ve helped military students and built strong education programs. These leaders can guide the next group of people5.
Dealing with the president shortage now will help universities later. It’s a big part of making sure schools stay great and grow. By training skilled leaders today, universities can tackle future problems and make lasting improvements3.
“The traditional ‘command and control’ leadership model is considered outdated due to changes in the workforce and work environment, underscoring the need for a new approach to higher education leadership.”
Student Success: Foundational Factors
Higher education success is shaped by various factors. These include background traits, experiences before college, and how students choose their courses. All these elements are vital in guiding a student’s learning path and achievements6.
Student Background Characteristics and Precollege Experiences
Characteristics like gender, race, and ethnicity greatly affect how well a student does. For example, the mix of male and female students can change success rates6. Also, having a diverse campus tends to boost achievement6. The level of challenge in a student’s high school work also predicts future success6.
The education levels of students’ parents matter too. Students often continue studying if their parents pursued their own education more deeply6. Money also has a big part, influencing if students stay in school and how they progress6. First-generation college students, those whose parents didn’t go to college, face unique hurdles6.
Enrollment Patterns
More students today attend multiple colleges. This trend affects how likely they are to finish their courses and how well they do academically. Understanding this trend is key to supporting students effectively6.
“Only a third of students describe their higher education experience as great, and 70% struggle with various mental health challenges during their college years.”7
Looking at students’ backgrounds, precollege life, and how they move through college helps us. This information is crucial for schools to support students. By focusing on these areas, institutions can help students do well and feel good about their experience6.
| Indicator | Findings |
|---|---|
| Mental Health Services Utilization | Students who used mental health services were more likely to have higher GPAs and be satisfied with their academic progress7. |
| Sense of Belonging | Students who felt a strong sense of belonging to their school community were more likely to have higher GPAs and be satisfied with their academic progress7. |
This shows that student success is complex. It involves looking at more than just grades. Creating a supportive atmosphere is key for students to flourish both in their studies and their well-being768.
Fostering Student Success: Key Behaviors and Experiences
To help students succeed in college, it’s important to know what behaviors and experiences matter. Engaging in good learning and taking part in cool college stuff can really boost a student’s chance to do well after high school9.
College Activities
When colleges pair students with a dedicated advisor, tell them about campus life, and kick off bridge programs before classes start, it helps. Plus, programs that teach time management and explore future job opportunities get students off to a good beginning9.
Alert advice for students who are struggling can make a big difference9. Also, getting students to think early about what they want to do after college, with real job market info and connections to former students, can bring success closer9.
Getting out there with hands-on learning, like internships and studying abroad, is a game changer. It helps students set clear career goals and sharpen their skills9. Offering extra support in tough times, like quick cash when it’s needed, can also help students stay in school9.
Building a culture of success with campus events and closer ties between students and teachers keeps minds on the right track. This means more students find their place and stay focused9.
Engagement in Effective Educational Practices
Simplifying degree hoops and making sure classes are available can push students to do better9. Studies also show that school programs designed to help students learn better and grow in every way can really make a difference10.
Putting in efforts that make classrooms feel welcoming can make students feel like they belong11. Being real and having flexible rules can lower stress and get more students involved11. Working together and giving feedback often makes everyone feel like they’re part of a caring community11.
Challenging courses that are clear and make sense engage students the most11. Honest tests that show what’s expected boost learning11. Believing that hard work pays off, and giving students a say in how they learn, is key to doing well in school11.
“Fostering a success-oriented mindset through campus activities and stronger student-faculty ties can improve student engagement.”
Institutional Conditions for Student Success
The conditions at higher education institutions are key for student success. They involve the setup, programs, and support provided. This includes how the place looks and runs, and the efforts made to help students.
Structural and Organizational Characteristics
Things like campus size, whether it’s public or private, and its design matter a lot. They influence how well students can do. Colleges that focus on serving minority groups often do a great job in helping students feel welcome and engaged.
Programs and Practices
Institutions often put in place special programs to help students make the most of their time. This could be anything from help with getting used to college life, to good advice about what classes to take. There are also ways to spot students who might need extra help, and programs that bring students with similar interests together.
Tinto and Pusser’s work underlines what helps students really succeed. They point out the need for colleges to be wholeheartedly for their students. This includes clear goals for success, strong support from the start, regular check-ins, and students really getting into their education. They also highlight how laws from the government matter, especially about getting ready for college, paying for it, and making sure the education is worth it12.
Another study about a certain college showed it was doing quite well. It had a high percentage of students coming back for a second year and graduating within six years. But even with these good numbers, the college wanted to do better. It aimed to offer more chances for students to learn and take part, use information better, and set higher goals for graduates. This shows the effort colleges put in to make sure students do well and the role everyone plays in making those efforts count13.
Research into giving students solid advice academically brings to light how important it is for the advice to be fair and connected to a love of learning. Plus, the people giving the advice need to keep getting better at what they do. Good advising not only helps students but also brings everyone at the college together. It keeps the college focused on its main goals and uses technology to make advice even better for students14.
Building Excellence: Singapore’s Experience
Singapore has worked hard for over 30 years to make its higher education system top-notch. It started with just one local university but now has six well-known, government-backed universities15. This change came about by closely linking the goals of education with the country’s needs. It has benefited everyone in Singapore16.
Investing heavily in research was key to Singapore’s progress. Making universities manage themselves was also crucial16. A book called “Building Excellence: Singapore’s Experience” by Arnoud De Meyer shares deep insights. It includes talks with important people from Singapore’s university world over the last 20 years15.
The book talks about what made Singapore stand out, like aiming for high student participation. It also mentions big money for education and research. Other winning points were smart plans, the ability to change, and learning from abroad16. Because of this, Singapore’s universities are now seen as leaders worldwide. Many people look up to them as an example17.
The book looks ahead too, talking about how teachers and university leaders work together and how much universities help with ongoing education. It also mentions the need to turn research into useful, new products16. These ideas show Singapore’s education world as a place full of growth and change. It’s a great guide for other countries looking to shine academically17.
| Key Factors in Singapore’s Higher Education Success | Outcomes |
|---|---|
|
|
Singapore’s journey to top-tier education offers important lessons for others. It shows how to make educational systems better and full of new ideas16. By following Singapore’s example, leaders and policy-makers can improve their own education systems17.
“The success of Singapore’s higher education system is a testament to the country’s unwavering commitment to educational excellence and its ability to adapt to the changing global landscape. Their experience provides a roadmap for other nations aspiring to build world-class universities and foster a thriving culture of academic engagement and innovation.”
Redefining Global Engagement Strategies
The globe has seen a massive rise in linked higher education, mainly through many international branch campuses (IBCs). It has sparked debate. Some see IBCs as a way to make education widely available and fill justice gaps. Others worry they might spread cultural imperialism18.
Research on almost 300 IBCs shows a detailed look at their global connections. This work uncovers how these campuses are scattered worldwide, affected by history and culture18. It looks into the network structures and key players, helping us understand IBCs and global education better. This info could guide future decisions in management and politics18.
The Globalisation of Higher Education
The growth of IBCs has hugely impacted global education. Take Georgetown University’s School of Continuing Studies, which saw 370 students from 85 nations in 2017–18. This was 13% of its total students seeking a degree18. The school also had 490 study abroad chances, making learning international18. This was a big shift from 2007 when it had just 32 foreign students and no study abroad programs18.
In search of a wider global audience, schools are setting up special programs. For example, Georgetown’s Qatar campus has offered various study options since 2005. It focuses on economic and professional growth18.
Universities have started many Master’s programs to meet wider global needs. These include areas like Emergency & Disaster Management. They come with study abroad components, offering hands-on learning worldwide18.
“The globalization of higher education has ushered in an era of unprecedented interconnectedness, exemplified by the proliferation of international branch campuses worldwide.”
While higher education’s global shift brings new chances, it also raises issues about equal sharing. Studies show IBCs are not evenly spread, leading to a core-periphery setup. This setup reflects old and new influences on global education18.
Universities must really think about their global plans. Understanding the true nature of global education can help navigate these challenges. This ensures that international efforts really do help with justice and benefit everyone181920.
Higher Education Innovation for Global Wellbeing
The COVID-19 pandemic has shown how important it is for universities to help the world. They need to focus on the Sustainable Development Goals21. This means changing how they work, so they benefit the world more than ever before21.
In the past, universities focused on making money and increasing their status. They did this by getting rich students from abroad to help pay for research21. But times have changed. Now, universities are asked to care more about fairness for everyone and the world’s future21.
It’s key for universities to rethink how they help the world meet its future goals21. They can do a lot by working together for fairness and a better future for everyone21.
Universities must use their knowledge and connections to help solve big global problems. These include climate change and helping poor and unequal societies21. By working together, they can make the world more fair and green21.
Reimagining what universities do for the world is a big, important change. It will make higher education more about helping the world than ever. And it’s not just good for universities; it’s great for the whole world too21.
“The future of higher education lies in its ability to embrace sustainable development, foster social justice, and make a tangible, positive impact on the global community.” – Dr. Emily Hathaway, Director of Global Engagement, University of Westfield
| Sustainable Development Goals | Higher Education’s Contribution |
|---|---|
| Goal 1: No Poverty | Conducting research on effective poverty alleviation strategies, providing educational opportunities for underserved communities, and collaborating with local organizations to address the root causes of poverty. |
| Goal 4: Quality Education | Improving access to quality education, developing innovative teaching and learning methods, and fostering global exchange of knowledge and best practices. |
| Goal 13: Climate Action | Advancing climate change research, implementing sustainable campus operations, and equipping students with the skills and knowledge to address environmental challenges. |
By innovating higher education, universities can spark positive change. They can help the world reach its goals, making it a fairer and greener place for all21. This change is big but brings huge benefits for universities and the whole planet212223.
Measuring Success: Outcomes and Indicators
Higher education success isn’t just about student numbers and grad rates. It’s about the change in students’ lives and the skills they gain24. Recent studies show that after college, what students do is the real reflection of success24. For colleges, this means they should look at what happens after graduation and how well students perform in their fields24.
College and Postcollege Indicators
We need more than what’s inside the school to measure education’s true worth24. Good measures should be clear, practical, and make sense in the real world24. For instance, focused efforts at California State University have really pushed up the rate at which students graduate in four years24. It’s suggested that schools focus on a few key points to check on students’ success going forward24.
Postcollege outcomes, such as jobs, income level, and happiness, offer a broader look at how successful students are.2425 Getting a bachelor’s degree is crucial for a good career and it’s a vital part of how we measure student success24. The type of degree matters too. Technical degrees might mean higher pay and more job satisfaction, according to research from Georgetown University24.
Learning and Personal Development Outcomes
Success in higher education should also mean personal growth and learning, not just earning power24. This includes things like thinking skills, learning new things, working well with others, and how you handle challenges24. By checking these things, schools can make sure what they teach matches what the job market needs24.
Take Louisiana, for instance, aiming for more working adults with valuable degrees by 203024. Georgia State saw a jump in graduation rates, particularly for those usually left behind, thanks to smart strategies2425. The time it takes to graduate is also seen as a key measure. It shows progress better than just looking at graduation rates24.
By looking beyond the usual measures, colleges can show how valuable their education really is242526. They can make sure they’re meeting the needs of students and society as it changes24.
“Measuring success in higher education requires a holistic approach that goes beyond traditional metrics and focuses on the real-world outcomes and personal development of students.”
Conclusion
This article shares special tips for doing well in higher education in the United States. It talks about the big changes happening in colleges and the key things that help students succeed. It also looks at the rules and conditions that support student growth27.
It learns from top schools and what the industry says. It shows how colleges need to connect with the world better and work on global issues. This way, colleges will prepare students for a future that’s more connected28.
The article stresses the importance of having a strong program, great teachers, important research, and getting ready for work. It says colleges must give students chances to meet others from around the world and learn how to work together. This is key for students to do well in the global job market29.
FAQ
What are the key factors driving disruption in the higher education landscape?
What are the foundational elements of student success in higher education?
What are the crucial behaviors, activities, and experiences that foster student success?
What institutional conditions, policies, programs, and practices are associated with positive student outcomes?
What can be learned from Singapore’s experience in building a successful higher education system?
How has the globalization of higher education, exemplified by the growth of international branch campuses, impacted the higher education landscape?
What are the new approaches to measuring the success of higher education institutions?
Source Links
- https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/industry/public-sector/latest-trends-in-higher-education.html – 2024 Higher Education Trends
- https://www.ecampusnews.com/campus-leadership/2024/05/08/5-trends-impacting-higher-eds-path-in-2024/ – 5 trends impacting higher ed’s path in 2024
- https://agb.org/trusteeship-article/leadership-in-times-of-crisis/ – Leadership in Times of Crisis
- https://www.fcevents.com/website/38112/ – FranklinCovey Higher Education Events
- https://www.acenet.edu/News-Room/Pages/Syverud-2024-Hesburgh-Award.aspx – TIAA Institute Honors Syracuse University’s Kent Syverud with Hesburgh Award for Leadership Excellence in Higher Education
- https://nces.ed.gov/npec/pdf/kuh_team_report.pdf – What Matters to Student Success: A Review of the Literature
- https://www.quadc.io/blog/student-success-and-student-well-being-whats-the-connection – Student Success and Student Well-being: What’s the Connection?
- https://www.aft.org/sites/default/files/media/2014/studentsuccess0311.pdf – PDF
- https://www.insidehighered.com/blogs/higher-ed-gamma/8-steps-institutions-need-take-improve-student-success – The 8 Steps Institutions Need to Take to Improve Student Success
- https://wacenter.evergreen.edu/sites/default/files/Academic and Student Affairs.pdf – LC and SA.indd
- https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/effective-teaching-strategies/increasing-student-success-a-developmental-approach/ – Increasing Student Success: A Developmental Approach
- https://nces.ed.gov/npec/pdf/tinto_pusser_report.pdf – Moving From Theory to Action: Building a Model of Institutional Access for Student Success
- https://studentsuccess.colostate.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/41/2020/01/PlanforExcellence_2006.pdf – Microsoft Word – Title Page 4.doc
- https://nacada.ksu.edu/Programs/Excellence-in-Academic-Advising.aspx – Excellence in Academic Advising
- https://www.routledge.com/Building-Excellence-in-Higher-Education-Singapores-Experience/DeMeyer-Ang/p/book/9780367539160 – Building Excellence in Higher Education: Singapore’s Experience
- https://archive.org/details/buildingexcellen0000meye – Building excellence in higher education : Singapore’s experience : Meyer, Arnoud de, author : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
- https://qs-gen.com/smu-launches-book-building-excellence-in-higher-education-singapores-experience/ – SMU launches book “Building Excellence in Higher Education: Singapore’s Experience”
- https://unbound.upcea.edu/innovation/contemporary-learners/strategic-global-engagement-in-the-school-of-continuing-studies-at-georgetown-university/ – Strategic Global Engagement in the School of Continuing Studies at Georgetown University | UNBOUND
- https://www.port.ac.uk/news-events-and-blogs/blogs/education-matters/creating-a-global-mindset – Creating a Global Mindset
- https://agb.org/trusteeship-article/higher-education-after-the-pandemic-are-we-still-a-global-industry/ – Higher Education After the Pandemic: Are We Still a Global Industry?
- https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/public-sector/solutions/higher-education-innovation-trends-about-center-for-higher-education-excellence.html – Exploring higher education innovation and trends | Deloitte US
- https://www.aacu.org/strategic-plan – Equity, Innovation, and Excellence | AAC&U
- https://www.luminafoundation.org/news-and-views/higher-education-linked-to-greater-wellbeing-job-fit-and-societal-progress-lumina-gallup-study-finds/ – Higher Education Linked to Greater Wellbeing, Job Fit and Societal Progress
- https://agb.org/trusteeship-article/measuring-student-success-beyond-completion/ – Measuring Student Success Beyond Completion
- https://clearpointstrategy.com/blog/key-performance-indicators-in-education – Key Performance Indicators For Schools & Education Managemen
- https://boardeffect.com/blog/key-performance-indicators-higher-education-boards/ – Key Performance Indicators in Higher Education Boards | BoardEffect
- http://oirap.rutgers.edu/msa/documents/eheguide5-29.pdf – PDF
- https://www.ed.gov/raisethebar/college-excellence-equity – Raise the Bar: College Excellence and Equity
- https://www.enqa.eu/wp-content/uploads/ENQA-Excellence-WG-Report_The-Concept-of-Excellence-in-Higher-Education.pdf – PDF